http://www.vinamtra.com.au/forum/index.php
Home Discussion Help Search Calendar Login Register
AMTRA.com.au
November 05, 2024, 03,36:10 PM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News:
This is the old AMTRA website.
You can only view the topics.
Copy and paste anything you would like to the new website.
 
Pages: [1] Topic: « previous next »
Print
Author Topic: DSMRA GRADING SYSTEM  (Read 7435 times)
Peter r
Full Member 2013/2014

Posts: 2482



« on: April 15, 2010, 11,10:08 AM »

Found this on the DSMRA Web site.
Who has a problem with this??? Cos i'm gunna change ours, like it or not??

 LEVEL 1, Easy

An easier dirt bike ride of mostly open fire trails for those with little or no dirt bike riding experience. May include a few obstacles but assistance will be provided if required.

LEVEL 2, Bit Harder

Moderate trail ride for those with some trail riding experience. Possibly some tricky sections and natural obstacles.

LEVEL 3, General

General trail ride for the competent rider with a well-maintained bike. May include single track, obstacles, river crossings, harder hills etc. Carry all your own equipment and have your bike well prepared.

LEVEL 4, Hard

Difficult and/or long ride recommended for experienced riders only. Carry all you own equipment and have your bike well prepared. Contact ride leader for details.
« Last Edit: April 15, 2010, 11,46:57 AM by Peter r » Logged
Ian Robinson
Administrator

Posts: 2551


Life Member


« Reply #1 on: April 15, 2010, 11,17:14 AM »

Ours has worked well for 40 years. Only those people who do not take the time to read it do not understand it.
And, it looks to me like the DSMRA have more or less copied OUR grading system.
I will oppose strongly any change to a system that has worked for so long and only does not work for those that fail to read it.
We have 4 levels only.
Level 1
Level 2.
Clubman
Experienced
and these are all that is needed.
Logged

Life member since Feb 82

Only a motorcyclist knows why a dog hangs its head out the window.
Peter r
Full Member 2013/2014

Posts: 2482



« Reply #2 on: April 15, 2010, 11,19:02 AM »

Ta just another kick in the head!!
Logged
Ian Robinson
Administrator

Posts: 2551


Life Member


« Reply #3 on: April 15, 2010, 11,20:07 AM »

Ta just another kick in the head!!

It was not meant to be.
Logged

Life member since Feb 82

Only a motorcyclist knows why a dog hangs its head out the window.
coolbananas1973
Guest
« Reply #4 on: April 15, 2010, 12,16:06 PM »

Looks to be basically the same pete except Level 3 called clubman and Level 4 called experienced......
Logged
Heiner

Posts: 7



« Reply #5 on: April 17, 2010, 02,46:02 AM »

Found this on the DSMRA Web site.
Who has a problem with this??? Cos i'm gunna change ours, like it or not??

 LEVEL 1, Easy

An easier dirt bike ride of mostly open fire trails for those with little or no dirt bike riding experience. May include a few obstacles but assistance will be provided if required.

LEVEL 2, Bit Harder

Moderate trail ride for those with some trail riding experience. Possibly some tricky sections and natural obstacles.

LEVEL 3, General

General trail ride for the competent rider with a well-maintained bike. May include single track, obstacles, river crossings, harder hills etc. Carry all your own equipment and have your bike well prepared.

LEVEL 4, Hard

Difficult and/or long ride recommended for experienced riders only. Carry all you own equipment and have your bike well prepared. Contact ride leader for details.

Both systems should work well. I only found one fault in the Amtra system.
The ride organizer/Leader deceits   the level of the ride.  As he is in most cases Expert level he’s under rating the ride level. What’s poo easy for him can be quiet hard for others.
I think it would be a good Idea that after every ride is over, he asked the other entire rider, as what level there would grade the ride. That would give him a better understanding of their ride capability.
I was on a recent Neerim south level 2 ride. I managed quiet well, but I would classify some of the Hills as Clubman close to Expert. 
Logged
Tim Dykes
Abbeyard Officer
Administrator

Posts: 1859


Where I want to be...


« Reply #6 on: April 17, 2010, 03,29:01 AM »

Found this on the DSMRA Web site.
Who has a problem with this??? Cos i'm gunna change ours, like it or not??

 LEVEL 1, Easy

An easier dirt bike ride of mostly open fire trails for those with little or no dirt bike riding experience. May include a few obstacles but assistance will be provided if required.

LEVEL 2, Bit Harder

Moderate trail ride for those with some trail riding experience. Possibly some tricky sections and natural obstacles.

LEVEL 3, General

General trail ride for the competent rider with a well-maintained bike. May include single track, obstacles, river crossings, harder hills etc. Carry all your own equipment and have your bike well prepared.

LEVEL 4, Hard

Difficult and/or long ride recommended for experienced riders only. Carry all you own equipment and have your bike well prepared. Contact ride leader for details.

Both systems should work well. I only found one fault in the Amtra system.
The ride organizer/Leader deceits   the level of the ride.  As he is in most cases Expert level he’s under rating the ride level. What’s poo easy for him can be quiet hard for others.
I think it would be a good Idea that after every ride is over, he asked the other entire rider, as what level there would grade the ride. That would give him a better understanding of their ride capability.
I was on a recent Neerim south level 2 ride. I managed quiet well, but I would classify some of the Hills as Clubman close to Expert. 


And another rider would call the same hill level 1 or 2  Huh

A level 2 ride takes in all terrain, it's just the speed you cover the ground and how much assistance is given that changes.
A level 2 ride leader is not going to take the group up a hill that's going to take 4 hours for the group to get up, that's not a days riding.
If after reading the info on the ride you have questions.
Phone the ride leader and ask them and they will answer your questions.

The grading system is a guide and is never going to be perfect Tongue
Logged

I can recall the day Australia went to the dogs...
The day that I had to pay for sauce on my pie.
Pages: [1] Topic: « previous next »
Print
GoogleTagged: com level powered 52164340 smf 53899372 51773540 amtra 90237346 peter
76247554 77161500 ride dgy south dirt dgc dgo 57155469 trails

 
Jump to:  
Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.4 | SMF © 2006-2007, Simple Machines LLC Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!


Google visited last this page August 27, 2024, 04,00:28 PM